Skip to main content

Cole-Cole Model

Cole-Cole Relaxation Model

The Cole-Cole model describes how the dielectric properties of materials change with frequency. In WFC applications, it provides a more accurate model of capacitance dispersion than the simple Randles circuit, especially for systems with distributed time constants.

Origin of the Cole-Cole Model

Kenneth and Robert Cole (1941) observed that many dielectric materials don't follow simple Debye relaxation. Instead, the relaxation is "stretched" across a broader frequency range. The Cole-Cole model quantifies this behavior with a single additional parameter.

The Cole-Cole Equation

Complex Permittivity:

ε*(ω) = ε∞ + (εs - ε∞) / [1 + (jωτ)(1-α)]

Where:

  • ε∞ = high-frequency (optical) permittivity
  • εs = static (DC) permittivity
  • τ = characteristic relaxation time
  • α = Cole-Cole parameter (0 ≤ α < 1)
  • ω = angular frequency (2πf)

The α Parameter

The Cole-Cole parameter α describes the "spread" of relaxation times:

α Value Behavior Physical Meaning
α = 0 Simple Debye relaxation Single relaxation time, ideal system
α = 0.1-0.3 Slight distribution Minor surface heterogeneity
α = 0.3-0.5 Moderate distribution Typical for WFC electrodes
α = 0.5-0.7 Broad distribution Rough or porous electrodes
α → 1 Extreme distribution Highly disordered system

Cole-Cole Plot

Plotting -ε'' vs. ε' creates the characteristic Cole-Cole diagram:

    -ε''
      ↑
      │
      │        Debye (α=0)             Cole-Cole (α>0)
      │          ○ ○ ○                    ○ ○ ○
      │       ○       ○                ○         ○
      │      ○         ○              ○           ○
      │     ○           ○            ○             ○
      │    ○             ○          ○               ○
      │                           ○                   ○
      │                         ○                       ○
      └────────────────────────────────────────────────────→ ε'
          ε∞        ε                ε∞        ε
                    ▲ s                        ▲ s
              Perfect                   Depressed
              semicircle                semicircle

     Center on           Center below
     real axis           real axis

The Cole-Cole model produces a depressed semicircle, with the center located below the real axis.

Depression Angle

The depression angle θ relates to α:

θ = α × (π/2) radians = α × 90°

Example: α = 0.3 gives θ = 27° depression

Physical Origins of Distribution

Why do WFC systems show Cole-Cole behavior?

  • Surface roughness: Different local environments at electrode surface
  • Porous electrodes: Distribution of pore sizes and depths
  • Oxide layers: Non-uniform thickness or composition
  • Grain boundaries: In polycrystalline electrodes
  • Adsorbed species: Non-uniform coverage of adsorbed ions

Impedance Form of Cole-Cole

For circuit modeling, the Cole-Cole element is expressed as impedance:

ZCC = R / [1 + (jωτ)(1-α)]

This can be represented as a resistor in parallel with a Constant Phase Element (CPE).

Cole-Cole in the VIC Matrix Calculator

The VIC Matrix Calculator uses the Cole-Cole model for WFC characterization:

Cole-Cole Parameters in the App:

alpha (α) Distribution parameter (0-1)
tau (τ) Characteristic time constant (seconds)
epsilon_s Static permittivity
epsilon_inf High-frequency permittivity

Frequency-Dependent Capacitance

The Cole-Cole model predicts how capacitance varies with frequency:

Effective Capacitance:

Ceff(ω) = C0 × [1 + (ωτ)2(1-α)]-1/2

At low frequency: Ceff → C0 (full capacitance)

At high frequency: Ceff → C∞ < C0 (reduced capacitance)

Practical Example

WFC with Cole-Cole Parameters:

  • τ = 10 µs (characteristic frequency ~16 kHz)
  • α = 0.4 (moderate distribution)
  • C0 = 10 nF (DC capacitance)

Effective Capacitance at Different Frequencies:

Frequency ωτ Ceff
100 Hz 0.006 ~10 nF (98%)
1 kHz 0.063 ~9.5 nF (95%)
10 kHz 0.63 ~7.5 nF (75%)
50 kHz 3.14 ~4 nF (40%)

VIC Design Implications

The Cole-Cole model affects VIC design in several ways:

  1. Resonant frequency shift: As frequency changes, Ceff changes, shifting resonance
  2. Broader resonance: The distribution of time constants broadens the frequency response
  3. Q factor reduction: Losses associated with the relaxation reduce circuit Q
  4. Frequency selection: Operating below the characteristic frequency maximizes capacitance

Practical Recommendation: For VIC circuits, choose an operating frequency below the Cole-Cole characteristic frequency (fc = 1/2πτ) to maximize effective WFC capacitance. The VIC Matrix Calculator can help determine optimal operating frequency based on your WFC's Cole-Cole parameters.

Next: Warburg Diffusion Impedance →

Back to top